“I saw her crying on the roof. I heard her saying that the world is not beautiful anymore .

She was unaware that i saw her shining like a diamond in the sky.” – Rohan Malhotra said that to the senior inspector who came near his building to investigate about the murder case of Naina Malik.

Naina Malik was a 21 year old,Journalist, Who attempted suicide last night that was, December 8.

Her family wittnessed that she had not committed suicide, she was murdered.

Where as, Rohan a 28 yearold , Photographer , who was trying to capture moon in his tiny little eyes, saw her committing suicide.

Who was right? No one knew !

Senior inspector , Nilesh Mathur, is the head incharge of  the case.

He is also wondering eyes cannot lie, so do the words ! Then who is actually lying ?

***

“Mom please, I don’t want to get married. Please, I love Sahil.

Papa, please ask mom not to fix anything “- Naina cried while saying this.

“Naina, who is Sahil that loser, Shut up, Papa, I just spoke to Rekha Aunty, she would be here in half n hour,”-Cried Naina’s brother,Nikhil.

“Bhai please, he is not a loser bhai, he is searching his job, and would soon get it.” “But bhai please, he was your best friend right?” -Naina said all that while crying.

” He WAS my friend, you have lost your mind, just keep your mouth shut”- Nikhil scolded Naina and held his phone in his hand and called another Friend Bikram.

“Hey Bikram , yeah. I am good bro, Tell me are you in touch with Sahil, yeah, Sahil Arora, Haa , he was my friend, we dont talk much, their were soem issues, yeah, Okh so givve his recent address to me, yeah, near Vasant Kunj? Ok V-A-S-A-N-T   P-U-R-I , ok thank you bro, no no problem, hahah okh bie bie, “-Nikhil had a conversation with his friend.

“Papa, That Sh*t is in Vasant Puri, i’ll go and get him, till then, Aunty will come just attend her,”- Nikhil asked his father.

“Nikhil is it ok to do all this, Naina is crying”- Their father calmly asked Nikhil.

“Let her cry, she had spoiled everything, that middle class won’t be my son-in-law”- Naina’s mother, cried while looking at Naina.

“Ma Papa, bhai, Please, i can’t stay without Sahil, Please.”- Naina said as she was crying.

“Shut up you bitch, Keep quite, “- Nikil Scolded Naina, while pushing her behind in her seat by her hair.

“Ahh, bhai please, its hurting”-Naina criedout her pain.

“Nikil stop this, have you lost it, get away from her, she is your sister”- Their father cried out and scolded Nikil while snaching her hand away from Naina.

 

AFTER 2 MONTHS

“Please come in,Nikhil, Call your mummy, its Rekha ji here, “- Nikhil’s dad called while opening the door.

“Ji Namaste, how are you? Naina is good?” -Their mom cried out while greeting Rekha ji.

“Hello, I am good, and Nainaa”- Rekha ji said so with great exhalation and stopped saying anything after calling out Naina’s name.

IT WAS THAT , BECAUSE OF CONTINUES FORCING NAINA’S PARENTS FORCED HER TO GET MARRIED. AND NIKHIL HAD ALSO FOUND SAHIL AND HAD JUST LEFT HIM ON A WARNING.

“What happened? Had Naina said you something? Is she ohk?” – Naina’s dad cried out with concern.

“What would happen to Naina? She is completely ok. She had made our lives miserable. “- Rekha ji screamed on Naina’s dad.

“Rekha ji Please tell us what happened?”- Naina’s dad felt a little worried about Naina’s earlier behavior relates to Sahil.

“What happened! She is crazy. She don’t even think before doing anything, whether she is always very opened up or whether she always want to annoy us.”- Rekha ji cried out loudly.

“Earlier she was always annoyed and now she is always screaming on us,as if we our her servants.She had not even allowed my son to touch her . Its been 2 months of her wedding. I am fed up of her behavior. She is really annoying. All i want to do at times is to kill her .. and. huh!”-Rekha ji was really upset and broke out.

“Rekha ji please calm down, we can understand your concern but please try to,. “Cride out Naina’s mom.

“What should i understand?You are talking rubbish,your daughter is mad . -Rekha ji cride out.

NAINA’S DAD  WAS FEELING REALLY BAD. HE LITERALLY FELL DOWN ON FLOOR. REKHA JI WAS STILL STANDING AND WATCHING NAINA’S DAD FELL DOWN SHE STARTED SAYING,

“I am pretty sure you people are hidding something from us.”- Rekha ji doubted the two parents.

“Rekha ji,their is nothing like what you are thinking,Its just,”-Naina’s mother was about to change the topic but Naina’s dad stopped her and said,

“There is no use to hide anything ,Seema, Everything is finished . I was telling Nikhil before hand only to tell everything to them,but no ,he never listen to what i say.”Cried out Naina’s dad.

“Tell me right now,what is their Shashi ji, tell me”-Cried out Rekha ji.

“Nothing Rekha ji , I will tell you soon but till then you sit here i’ll get some tea for you.”-Naina’s Mother tried to change the topic again,but failed again.

“Please Seema ji, I want to know.””You people better tell me”-Now Rekha ji had become really serious about the topic.

NAINA’S DAD DID NOT WANTED TO HIDE ANYTHING NAD HE SPOKE UP EVERYTHING.

REKHA JI LEFT WITHOUT SPEAKING ANYTHING.

 

NEXT DAY

DOOR BELL RANG

“Coming coming,Mumma make tea for me,”- Nikhil cried out while opening the door.

IT WAS NAINA ON THE DOOR WITH ALL HER STUFF AND DIVORCE PAPERS IN HER HAND. SHE WAS SMILING AND AS HER BROTHER OPENED THE DOOR SHE SAID,

“I did it, i am back. hahhahah, I am so happy now,”- Naina had tears in her eyes and broad smile on her face.

“Naina,you here, what is all this?”- Nikhil was confused to see Naina there back

“Naina,Bacha, I was knowing about it, This is going to happen, Your dad had spoiled your life “- Cried out Naina’s mother.

“No,It is not Dad who destroyed my life. It is you guyz”-Naina broke out into deep tears.

“I had told you guyz that i don’t want to get married that soon but you did’nt listned to what i said.Now see I am back. hahhah”- Naina was still crying.

 

“Naina, Shut up. “- Nikhil became furious and screamed on Naina.

“Shhhhh.. Now i won’t be listening to anyone of you.I am going to Sahil and would be staying with him.”- Naina screamed more loudly.

“You better not go to that guy back.You got that.”- Nikhil said again.

“Why should i listen to you Bhai,after all what you did to me?You really expect that from me now?Sorry but now i cannot do that.”- Naina said in a very calm voice and strongly.

“NAINA”-Nikil very loudly said that to Naina and was just about to slap.her when Naina holded his hand.

“You better not Mr. Nikil Malik., I am not your sister now.Your sister had died the day you decided about my life “- Naina said so.

 

PRESENT DAY.

IN THE POLICE STATION

“Sir, here is Mr Agnihotri.He is Malik’s neighbour.”- Sun inspector Jaishankar Pandey said.

“Hmm. Hello, Please sit”-The inspector said.

“Hello Sir,”- Mr Agnihotri said.

“Hmm hello, Can you tell me that you knew Naina? And how was her brother?”-Asked the senior inspector

“Sir. Actually,Naina was always beaten up by her brother. I had heard her screaming my a times.”-said,Mr Agnihotri.

“What,he used to beat her,but he was the one who said i love my sister very much and all”- the inspector Crossquestioned .

“Aree no no sir,he must be lying sir, i have myself heard her crying and asking her stop to stop beating her.”- Agnihotri gave his explanation.

“Ohk. You can leave now”- Inspector asked him to leave.

THE INSPECTOR WAS CONFUSED. FIRSTLY MALIK FAMILY WAS SAYING THEIR DAUGHTER HAD BEEN MURDERED BY HER EX BOYFRIEND Sahil AND SECONDLY Rohan HAD SEEN HER JUMPING FROM THE CLIFF AND ALSO NOW THIS Agnihotri HAD SEEN NAINA’S BROTHER BEATING HER OWN SISTER.

 

“Sir,Who is saying truth? I am getting confused now”-sub inspector said.

“Hmm. Even i am getting confused.Something is their which is not correct”-said the inspector.

 

NEXT DAY

“Sir i have got to know this really important factabout NAINA MALIK’S case.”-said sub inspector

“What ? tell me. “- asked the inspector.

THE SUB INSPECTOR TOLD EVERYTHING ABOUT NAINA AND HER MARRIAGE. AND ALSO INFORMED THAT NAINA’S MOTHER IN LAW HAD LEFT HER ALSO THAT AGNIHOTRI WAS RIGHT THAT NIKHIL THAT IS NAINA’S BROTHER USED TO BEAT HER.

“Oh my god, This is getting crazy, find Sahil. Where is he? “-inspector ordered his men.

 

LATER NEXT DAY

“Yes yes, Sir everything is going well sir,no no. ohk sir,yeah..ah.,Ok ok sir”-Inspector was talking to Commissioner on phone.

“Yes,Say,what have you got to know,”-inspector asked the sub inspector.

“Sir,SAHIL IS DEAD”-sub inspector informed The inspector.

“WHAT,ARE YOU SURE?”-the inspector asked the sub inspector.

THE SUB INSPECTOR INFORMED EVERYTHING THAT NIKHIL ,NAINA’S BROTHER KILLED SAHIL. AND SINCE SAHIL DIED, NAINA DID SUICIDE.

“Oh God, Call Nikil immediately and ask him to come here,and yes don’t tell him why we are calling him”- Inspector instructed his men to call NIKHIL.

SUB INSPECTOR CALLED NIKHIL AND ASK HIM TO COME.

“Sir have you found that bloody Sahil who killed my sister “- asked Nikhil.

“YES YES WE HAVE FOUND WHO KILLED YOUR SISTER,YOU YOURSELF KILLED HER MR NIKHIL MALIK “YOU KILLED HER “- inspector screamed at NIKHIL.

“Ahhmm.. what what. please sir.what are  you saying ? I have not killed my sister. Why would i kill her sir?”- Nikhil got a little hopeless while speaking all that.

“YOU HAVE KILLED HER,NOT INTENTIALLY BUT YES YOU HAVE KILLED SAHIL AND BECAUSE OF THAT NAINA COMMITTED SUICIDE”- inspector screamed on NIKHIL.

“YES YES YES, I DID I DID KILLED SAHIL. HE IS A RASCAL. HE IS A MIDDLE CLASS POOR STREET DOG WHO I HAD USED FOR MY PURPOSE BUT HE TRIED TO MAKE LOVE WITH MY SISTER,AND HENCE I KILLED HIM. HE DESERVED TO DIE . HE WANTED TO DIE. “-  nikhil showed all his agression.

“And yes now you deserve to go behind the bars “”Shinde, throw him inside”- inspector said

NAINA DIED BECAUSE OF HER FAMILY’S DECISION TO KEEP HER AWAY FROM SAHIL,BUT IN THE END THE TWO WERE TOGETHER IN THE HEAVEN.!!